Staff Picks

Gregorian’s ‘The Sound of Silence’ Reopened the Disturbed Debate

Gregorian’s “The Sound of Silence” is beautiful. One listener still says that once you’ve heard Disturbed, there’s no going back.

This performance comes from Gregorian’s Epic Chants tour in 2013. The group approaches ‘The Sound of Silence’ with several singers holding the melody in common. The Simon & Garfunkel song is familiar enough to make even small changes in the texture stand out.

A much-liked comment beneath Gregorian’s footage gave the choir credit before returning to one favorite version. The comparison helps describe the difference between these arrangements. In Gregorian, several voices share the outline of the song. In Disturbed, listeners can follow a single lead voice through a much more pronounced rise in intensity.

Gregorian gives the melody a group voice. Disturbed lets David Draiman’s lead carry much of the tension. Each arrangement asks the listener to wait for a different kind of release. Try the opening of each performance and listen for the exact moment the sound begins to feel bigger.

Listen to the voices separately from the stage picture for a moment. It is an easy way to hear how the melody holds its shape while the size of the sound changes.

The two covers make it easy to hear where an arrangement begins to build tension and when it lets that tension go.

A Vintage Song Era viewer’s first reaction to Gregorian’s ‘The Sound of Silence’ was that they still preferred Disturbed. The 2013 Gregorian performance makes the comparison interesting because both versions build weight around the same words in different ways.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *