An Audience Member Didn’t Expect Art Garfunkel at the Lennon Tribute
Art Garfunkel walking out to sing “Imagine” with Graham Nash and Judy Collins was a surprise to someone in the room.
Theatre Within held its 43rd annual John Lennon tribute in December 2023. Graham Nash, Judy Collins and Art Garfunkel shared ‘Imagine,’ supported by a full ensemble. The choice united musicians from different corners of the folk and rock records that made vocal harmony familiar to millions.
One attendee remembered Art Garfunkel’s appearance as the pleasant surprise of the evening. That detail points to a particular pleasure of a tribute concert. A familiar song gives the audience its bearings, then the people gathered around it can make the performance feel entirely new.
Start by listening for the individual singers. Then pay attention to the parts where the voices meet. You can still hear the different colors within the blend, which is what gives the performance its character. Few songs make that contrast as easy to hear as ‘Imagine.’
A tribute lets a familiar song reach listeners at different points in their lives. The camera catches the ensemble as it was on that evening, and the recording takes that moment out into other rooms.
Listen for the harmony when the three voices share a phrase.
Graham Nash, Judy Collins and Art Garfunkel can each make a phrase recognizable in a few syllables. The 43rd Annual John Lennon Tribute brings them together over a melody that hardly needs an introduction. That combination makes the harmonies as compelling as the names on the bill.



