A Lennon Tribute That Made Seventy Years Seem to Pass in a Blink
A listener measured the performance in decades. Nash, Collins and Garfunkel came to prominence by different routes, and their records have accompanied listeners through very different parts of their lives. The comment makes clear how quickly an old song can bring that history back.
Theatre Within held its 43rd annual John Lennon tribute in December 2023. Graham Nash, Judy Collins and Art Garfunkel shared ‘Imagine,’ supported by a full ensemble. The choice united musicians from different corners of the folk and rock records that made vocal harmony familiar to millions.
Theatre Within’s annual Lennon tribute has a straightforward premise. Ask musicians with their own histories to spend an evening inside someone else’s songs. In December 2023, the performers it brought together for ‘Imagine’ had already made enough records to fill three separate nights.
Nash, Collins and Garfunkel came to prominence along different paths, but all made records where melody and harmony mattered. Lennon’s song gave them a shared starting point. Watching the full performance, you hear a gathering of peers choosing to spend part of the evening with a single, widely shared tune.
A tribute lets a familiar song reach listeners at different points in their lives. The camera catches the ensemble as it was on that evening, and the recording takes that moment out into other rooms.
The 2023 event makes an old record feel like something happening between the people in the room.
Theatre Within’s annual Lennon tribute has a straightforward premise. Ask musicians with their own histories to spend an evening inside someone else’s songs. In December 2023, the performers it brought together for ‘Imagine’ had already made enough records to fill three separate nights.



