Staff Picks

Why Adam Lambert’s Idol Result Is Still an Argument

Adam Lambert finished second on American Idol in 2009. Some viewers are still calling it the biggest upset in the show’s history.

Adam Lambert’s eighth season of American Idol offers an unusually varied run of performances to revisit. The 2009 footage makes it possible to put the arrangement, vocal and reaction back into the room before later success or the finale result enters the story.

Kris Allen won the eighth season, and Lambert finished second. The years since have given the discussion a different context. A 2009 vote could choose a winner for that broadcast, but the performances Lambert gave over the course of the season remained available for later audiences to judge on their own terms.

The stage footage makes it easy to understand the persistence of that discussion. Over one season Lambert took on songs that made very different demands on a singer. Watching the sequence restores the question the finale can obscure: what did viewers hear in him before any winner was announced?

The show gave singers a short time to put their stamp on very different material. The full performance sequences preserve room for that choice before the judges or the results take over.

The older footage gives the voting debate something specific to turn on. Hear the range of song choices before coming back to the result.

Adam Lambert left the eighth season of American Idol as the runner-up. Years later, a compilation of his performances can still send the conversation back to the result. Some Vintage Song Era viewers said they preferred the career that followed; others wrote that they stopped watching after he lost.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aFCgIkG1Ttc

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *