American Idol 2025 Finale Results Trigger Viewer Outrage, with Carrie Underwood’s Judging Style Drawing Heavy Criticism
The American Idol Season 23 finale, held on May 18, 2025, ended with Jamal Roberts being named the winner—but the result didn’t sit well with everyone. Many fans, particularly those who supported runner-up John Foster, voiced strong opposition online, sparking one of the most heated reactions the show has seen in years.
Despite a record-breaking 26 million votes and massive viewership, the finale’s outcome quickly became a lightning rod for criticism. From fan forums to TikTok duets, debate over who truly deserved the title spread fast. The excitement of the finale was immediately met with a tidal wave of mixed emotions.
Jamal Roberts Wins, But John Foster Fans Cry Foul
After Roberts was announced as the winner, the show’s official Facebook page posted a celebratory photo of him holding his daughters alongside a winner’s gift set. Instead of cheers, the comments section was filled with disappointment and anger from Foster’s supporters.
Across social platforms, fans didn’t hold back. Some of the most repeated reactions included:
- “John should have won. He was so natural.”
- “Another rigged season.”
- “Jamal screams too much — John was robbed.”
- “I won’t watch next season. Foster deserved better.”
Many praised Foster’s consistency, authenticity, and original songwriting throughout the season. For some, his down-to-earth vibe and classic country tone were exactly what made him feel like the true winner of the competition.
A few viewers, however, offered a different take:
“Maybe it’s a good thing. Now John’s free from the Idol contract.”
Carrie Underwood’s Guest Judge Role Draws Mixed Reactions
The controversy didn’t end with the results. Carrie Underwood, who served as a guest judge during the Top 5 Disney Night episode on May 12, also faced backlash. Dressed as Rapunzel in a dramatic purple gown, she brought fairytale glamour to the panel—but her critiques didn’t feel magical to everyone.
Some viewers accused Underwood of showing clear favoritism during the episode, particularly with her comments toward Jamal Roberts. The backlash was swift and vocal:
- “Get rid of her. Her bias is showing.”
- “I wish there was a way to vote her off.”
- “Why so hard on Jamal? He’s amazing.”
- “Jelly Roll please, she’s got to go!”
Not all responses were negative. A segment of fans stood by Underwood’s judging style:
- “You’re still going to get criticized, so might as well do whatever you want!”
- “I loved you as a judge. Hope you come back next year.”
Disney Night Recap: The Songs That Decided the Top 3
The Disney-themed episode shaped the season’s final trio: John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Breanna Nix. Their performances were memorable and varied, showing their range in both genre and emotional delivery:
- John Foster: “The Bare Necessities” (The Jungle Book), “Rainbow Connection” (The Muppet Movie)
- Jamal Roberts: “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” (Remember the Titans), “Beauty and the Beast”
- Breanna Nix: “This Will Be (An Everlasting Love)” (The Parent Trap), “You’ll Be in My Heart” (Tarzan)
That night, Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis were eliminated, leaving behind a fiercely competitive final three.
Final Thoughts: A Divisive Season That Still Delivered
With Jamal Roberts officially crowned and John Foster widely embraced as the people’s champ, American Idol Season 23 wrapped up with passionate fan debates and unforgettable performances.
The final results may remain controversial, but one thing is certain: the conversations around American Idol 2025 are far from over. Whether you agreed with the outcome or not, the show succeeded in stirring emotion, building loyalty, and proving once again why it’s still one of the most talked-about competitions in America.
